‘Cultural shift’ at spending review can make public money work harder

Latest News Tue, Oct 29, 2024 6:56 AM

Strengthening incentives for cross-government working; a sharper focus on long-term outcomes; and better transparency are the hallmarks of an improved approach to government planning and spending, according to a new National Audit Office (NAO) report.

Lessons learned: a planning and spending framework that enables long-term value for money comprises eight lessons to help ministers and senior officials as they plan the 2025 Spending Review. The report is also intended to help Parliamentarians and other stakeholders scrutinise government spending and delivery.

Spending reviews were first introduced in 1998 to address inadequate government long-term planning by replacing yearly cash budgets with a system distinguishing between capital investment and day-today government spending. When NAO last examined this topic in 2018, it found underlying weaknesses, including spending decisions taken on poor data and evidence.

There have been some positive developments since the NAO last reported, including the introduction of the HM Treasury’s (HMT) Shared Outcomes Fund to test innovative ways of joining up planning and spending across the public sector.

The NAO’s report, Reducing harm from illegal drugs, documented how senior leadership and strong governance can make a difference on joint departmental working. But despite clear HMT guidance, Whitehall’s finance ministry has received fewer joint bids than it would have hoped for.

Recent national and global crises have resulted in an increasingly short-term, reactive approach to government spending. Consequently, there has been no multi-year spending review since 2021, as decision-makers dealt with the immediate economic challenges of COVID-19 and then energy price rises, rather than focusing on long-term planning.

Transparency has also waned in recent years, with departmental outcome delivery plans – tracking progress against government priorities – unpublished since 2021. It is important for government to be transparent about its objectives, plans, spending choices and risk appetite and assessments, as well as the performance and outcomes delivered.

Previous closed and competitive approaches to spending reviews led to the use of unrealistic cost estimates to gain approvals for major projects, alongside a failure to plan for inflation. As Parliament has observed, these missteps are often exacerbated by official and ministerial churn, which in turn affects accountability.

The NAO’s recommendations focus on adding greater transparency to government planning and spending, embedding good behaviours and building in evaluation from the outset.

They include:

  • Annually publishing departmental outcome delivery plans and cross-cutting mission board plans.
  • Publishing (post spending review) a summary of spending choices with sufficient data allowing an understanding of allocations by department, priority outcome and strategic programme.
  • HM Treasury and Cabinet Office to re-balance behaviour and decision-making towards long-term value for money, backed by senior ministerial and official leadership.

Gareth Davies, head of the NAO, said: “Limited resources, amid growing challenges and ambitious missions, means real change is needed if the next spending review is to set up the government for future success.

“The government can use the planning and spending framework to help make a cultural shift towards a focus on long-term value for money.

“Our report makes practical recommendations to support this change.”

Featured News

Specification news
Flying the Flag: Ravatherm XPS X is ‘Made in...

King’s Lynn Manufacturer, Ravago Building Solutions UK, has joined the ‘Made in...

Read More >>

Specification news
Reforms to get Britain building will boost economy by...

Planning reforms to accelerate the delivery of new homes, roads and railways, and...

Read More >>

BUILDING PRODUCT LIBRARY - LATEST BROCHURES

AKW Bathroom Catalogue 2025 Brochure

AKW Bathroom Catalog...
By AKW

Download Now >>

Baths Collection Brochure Brochure

Baths Collection Bro...
By AKW

Download Now >>

Your high performance facade panel. With James Hardie, It’s Possible™ Brochure

Your high performanc...
By James Hardie

Download Now >>

James Hardie brings unique designs to life with beautiful fibre cement products that are built to last. It’s Possible™ Brochure

James Hardie brings...
By James Hardie

Download Now >>

fermacell® The Specification Guide Brochure

fermacell® The Speci...
By James Hardie

Download Now >>

BUILDING PRODUCT DIRECTORY - LATEST PRODUCTS

SOPRALENE FLAM 180 AF
SOPRALENE FLAM 180 AF

Membrane composed of elastomer modified bitumen and a non woven polyester reinforcement.The upper...

Read More >>

FLAGON SR DE PVC
FLAGON SR DE PVC

Membrane composed of flexible PVC and a polyester reinforcement. Available in different RAL...

Read More >>

FLAGON S PVC
FLAGON S PVC

Membrane composed of flexible PVC. Available in different RAL Colours.Used for detailing work. The...

Read More >>

CONSTRUCTION VIDEOS - LATEST VIDEOS

Why our Canopies Last Longer
Why our Canopies Last Longer

https://www.aandslandscape.co.uk/ Find out why A&S Landscape Canopies last longer than alternatives....

Watch Now >>

Enclosed Dining Canopy - Hampton Gardens School
Enclosed Dining Canopy - Hampton Gardens School

A&S Landscape designed and installed a large enclosed, curved roof canopy for Hampton Gardens School...

Watch Now >>

Dining Area Canopy at John Spendluffe Technology College
Dining Area Canopy at John Spendluffe Technology College

We designed and installed a new dining area canopy for John Spendluffe Technology College. This has...

Watch Now >>