LABC condemns MHCLG ‘sleight of hand’ on safety reform

Latest News Tue, Jul 9, 2019 1:59 PM

LABC is deeply concerned after hearing from a senior official at MHCLG that the ministry intends to allow Approved Inspectors a continued role in the regulation of in scope buildings.

In the current consultation Dame Judith Hackitt’s Joint Competent Authority has been dropped in favour of a new Building Safety Regulator.

The MHCLG consultation states in para 317: The specific organisational model for the building safety regulator, how it will be structured, where it will be housed, lines of accountability, and the sourcing of necessary capacity and expertise have still to be determined.

LABC has been informed that an existing national regulator has been told to take control of the implementation with the specific direction to involve private sector organisations in compliance.

Lorna Stimpson, LABC’s Deputy Chief Executive explains: “MHCLG is currently consulting on proposals to reform the building safety regulatory system. We have contributed thousands of hours of voluntary help to officials who said that they were implementing all 53 recommendations of the Hackitt Review. But now we are told two of the Review’s main pillars – a single strong undisputed regulator and the removal of choice from those who regulate high risk projects – have been completely undermined by this new policy switch.

“This switch also undermines the consultation, which is framed in terms of how the MHCLG is implementing all 53 Hackitt recommendations. The failure to explain ministry intentions for the new regime will allow the civil service to claim the consultation is supported by industry – but support for what? This is a sleight of hand. They haven’t declared that competing interests will remain at the centre of high-risk regulation."

Paul Everall, LABC Chief Executive, added: “As a former senior civil servant I’m disappointed and saddened to see this consultation weakened by the ministry’s lack of transparency. The structure has been deliberately obscured to give maximum freedom to civil servants. It isn’t possible for responders to question this because feedback has been focussed on pre-set questions – you can’t question something that’s not revealed. Clearly there’s an agenda here – which is ensure a role for private sector consultants in building safety regulation that is at odds with the recommendations of Dame Judith.”

Dame Judith Hackitt warned against such a proposal. She wrote, the creation of the JCA is considered to be more appropriate than the creation of an entirely new single regulator that draws building safety expertise away from three pre-existing organisations who would still have critical work to take forward.

MHCLG officials had been trying to retain the experience and expertise of Approved Inspectors in the system as Dame Judith originally envisaged in an additional consultancy or compliance support role for dutyholders and to provide additional capacity for local authorities. But now it appears private sector inspectors have been elevated to full independent regulatory involvement. Yet Dame Judith could not have been clearer. She said, (there is) a cultural issue across the sector, which can be described as a ‘race to the bottom' and she called for a single, streamlined, regulatory route for the provision of building control as set out in paragraphs 2.43-2.45 above with oversight solely provided through Local Authority Building Control.

Paul Everall continued by highlighting the strategic impacts of this confused policy. “LABC and the vast majority of professionals agreed with the Hackitt recommendations because they understood the problems. Having promised not to do so, MHCLG is creating a two-tier system with a centralised and bureaucratic regulator that consumes expertise from the rest of the system. More than that, Approved Inspectors will use their contribution to the new regulator to claim full equality with the public regulatory service. Long term this will put pressure on local authorities and their professional building control teams.

"Public safety will be put at risk with functions like dangerous structures, safety at sports grounds and major events, consumer protection and free disabled facility work stopping because there will be fewer and fewer highly competent LABC surveyors in public service.

“Ultimately communities will pay the cost. Compliance will become a bought commodity.”

LABC is seeking urgent meetings with MHCLG and Dame Judith herself to make clear its deep concerns over this new direction and its inherent risks to life safety. It is also briefing its 3,500 strong network and encouraging them to lobby local elected members and MPs about MHCLG’s true direction of travel.

LABC members are taking part in local authority briefings supported by the LGA. And during the summer LABC will convene a professionals and industry review of the consultation to create and publish an alternative model.

Paul Everall concluded, urging LABC members to participate in the consultation. “LABC members should take part. The consultation has some useful elements. However, I strongly urge everyone to try to make additional comments to question the ministry’s behind the scenes u-turn. I also recommend writing to the Minister or senior officials to ask why promises to implement 100% of Hackitt have been dropped and turned into something unrecognisable from the original clear concept.”

Featured News

Specification news
Compliance and performance without compromise -...

UK MANUFACTURER PERMAROCK PRODUCTS LTD HAS SUPPLIED ONE OF ITS THERMAL EXTERNAL WALL...

Read More >>

Specification news
Smoke control at West Kowloon Rail Terminus stays on...

HONG KONG'S WEST KOWLOON RAIL TERMINUS IS USING MORE THAN 800 ACTUATORS FROM SE...

Read More >>

BUILDING PRODUCT LIBRARY - LATEST BROCHURES

CLD Fencing Systems Brochure

CLD Fencing Systems
By CLD Fencing Systems

Download Now >>

Universal Eaves Vent  Systems Brochure

Universal Eaves Vent...
By Marley Ltd

Download Now >>

Universal Dry Verge  System Brochure

Universal Dry Verge...
By Marley Ltd

Download Now >>

Roofing Top Training 2019 Brochure

Roofing Top Training...
By Marley Ltd

Download Now >>

Tile Vent Terminals  Brochure

Tile Vent Terminals
By Marley Ltd

Download Now >>

BUILDING PRODUCT DIRECTORY - LATEST PRODUCTS

JB Green
JB Green

Premium Type A timber batten for a wide range of applications.Made from slow-grown, kiln dried...

Read More >>

Wessex
Wessex

All of our concrete interlocking tiles can achieve an 'A+' rating (which has the lowest...

Read More >>

Riven Edgemere
Riven Edgemere

Riven Edgemere is a single lap solution, that allows quick and easy installation, and is compatible...

Read More >>

CONSTRUCTION VIDEOS - LATEST VIDEOS

Marley Handmade Tiles
Marley Handmade Tiles

True to tradition, a range of three distinctive handmade clay plain tiles colours, with a fine...

Watch Now >>

Binton Road - Case Study
Binton Road - Case Study

Marley Hawkins clay plain tiles in a Fired Sienna colour were a perfect roofing option for 4 new...

Watch Now >>

Pine Lake - Case Study
Pine Lake - Case Study

Western Red Cedar Shingles used on a property in Ayshire.

Watch Now >>